Jaziratul Khidra

Salaam un alaikum,

Are anyone of you in town? What is happening?

Take a look at this discussion about the Island where Imam al Mahdi (ATF) is said to be residing – Jazira Khadra’. I have copied a small part of the discussion http://www.al-islam.org/mahdi/nontl/Chap-10.htm . The complete book can be referred to here: http://www.al-islam.org/mahdi/nontl/Toc.htm.

Mr. Hoshyar: The story of Jazira Khadra’ is as I have narrated for you in brief. Let me hasten to add that this story has no credibility and that it resembles a legend and a fiction for the following reasons:

First, its chain of transmission (sanad) is unreliable. The story has been taken from an unidentified manuscript. ‘Allama Majlisi himself says thus: “Since I have not found this story in any authentic book, I created a special section to report it [so that it does not get mixed up with the other reliable contents of Bihar al-anwar].”

Second, there are a number of inconsistencies in the narrative. I am sure you noticed that in one place Sayyid Shams al-Din tells the narrator that he was the deputy of the Imam, but he had not seen him. Moreover, he says: “. . . but my father used to say that he would hear his voice but could not see him. But my grandfather used to hear his voice and see him too.” The same Sayyid later on says that he sees the Imam every Friday morning and encourages the narrator to do the same. The Shaykh who brought the narrator to that island also tells him that the Sayyid and those like him are the only ones who can meet with the Imam. As you have noticed this is a contradictory statement. The interesting part of the story is that if the Sayyid knew that he was the only one who could meet with the Imam, why did he propose to the narrator that he should go to the mountain and see the Imam?

Third, the story makes reference to alterations in the Qur’an, and such a view is impossible to maintain. Muslims scholars have unanimously rejected such a contention about the Holy Book of God.

Fourth, the lawfulness of the khums has been touched upon in the story, which, according to the jurists, is unacceptable.

Advertisements

4 responses to “Jaziratul Khidra

  1. Ahmad Husaini

    We cannot say where the Imam(A) resides….. it is foolish to point out places like the Bermuda Triangle or Jazeerat al-Khadraa!

  2. I am glad that at least someone agrees 🙂

    I would also like to hear from those who do not…

    PS. Ahmad where are you? in Dubai?

  3. Ahmad Husaini

    Yes, Muslim Sir, I am in Sharjah, but only for 10 more days. I did not understand properly how the extra classes for Gr11 were going on, as I was not informed properly. I will be going to New Delhi on the 30th inshaallah.

  4. Was looking for proof to be able to refute the ‘myth’! Amazing how this concept seems to be a reality for most, inspite of the fact that he have an authentic hadith that states that anyone who claims to be Imam’s representative in the major occultation, or even have met him, is a liar!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s